The Independent Order

Government => Conference Hall => Topic started by: Beatrice on February 27, 2022, 12:52:33 PM

Title: Proposed Constitution - For The Regional Assembly
Post by: Beatrice on February 27, 2022, 12:52:33 PM
Constitution of the Independent Order


WHEREAS the members of the Independent Order have, after due time and consideration, determined that there shall exist a single Constitution with supreme authority over all laws,

BE IT ENACTED by Her Excellency the Grand Chancellor, by and with the advice and consent of the Regional Assembly, and by the authority of the same, as follows:

Article One: The Chancellery

(1) The Grand Chancellor shall be the Head of Government and Head of State of the Order, and Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces of The Independent Order.

(2) The Grand Chancellor shall be responsible for:
   
(3) The Grand Chancellor may be recalled following a referendum of 3/4th of all eligible members of the Independent Order voting in favour, as defined by law. Should a Grand Chancellor be recalled, then a Constitutional Convention shall be required to appoint a replacement.

Article Two: Legislation

(4) The Grand Chancellor may enact any legislation, including amendments to the Constitution, Criminal Code and Roleplay Rules.

(5) Any enactment made shall be known as Acts of the Chancellery.

(6) The Grand Chancellor must, when seeking to make such legislative changes, publicly post, and announce on Discord, the regional message board and any other relevant areas, the proposed Act in the Conference Hall.

(7) The Act must remain in the Conference Hall, open for public debate or opposition, for a minimum of 72 hours, unless such an Act would amend the Constitution, Criminal Code, Emergency Procedures or Roleplay Rules, where it must be open for at least 96 hours.

(8) No Act amending the Roleplay Rules proposed initially by the Grand Chancellor may be enacted without the advice and consent of the Roleplay Magistrate, except where the enactment is approved by a referendum of eligible members.

(9) Any eligible member may petition in the Conference Hall thread to block an Act. Should the petition receive two further signatures from eligible members while the Act is in the Conference Hall, then the Act shall be subject to referendum of all eligible members.

(10) Any eligible member may bring forward their own legislation and, with the support of four further eligible members, require the Bill to be brought to a referendum of all eligible members.

(11) The Grand Chancellor may, where authorised or required by law to do so, issue a statutory instrument known as an Order of the Chancellory (herein ‘Order’). No Order shall need prior approval, however, any eligible member may bring forward, to the Conference Hall, a petition to repeal the Order. Should the petition receive four further signatures from eligible members, then the Order must be withdrawn.”

Article Four: The Roleplay Magistrate

(12) There shall be a Roleplay Magistrate responsible for the enforcement of roleplay rules.

(13) The Roleplay Magistrate shall be appointed by the Grand Chancellor for an indefinite term. The Roleplay Magistrate may be dismissed by the Grand Chancellor, or may be recalled following a referendum of all eligible members of the Independent Order, as defined by law.

(14) The Roleplay Magistrate shall:

(15) When enforcing the Roleplay Rules, the Roleplay Magistrate must:

Article Five: The Judiciary

(16) The Judiciary shall be headed by the Lord Chief Justice.

(17) The Lord Chief Justice shall be appointed by the Grand Chancellor for an indefinite term. The Lord Chief Justice may be dismissed by the Grand Chancellor, or may be recalled following a referendum of all eligible members of the Independent Order, as defined by law.

(18) The Lord Chief Justice shall be responsible for:

(19) Should the Lord Chief Justice determine that a body has acted ultra vires, or that elections were not free and fair, they may issue an Order of the Judiciary (‘Judicial Order’) to remedy the matter, as defined by law.

Article Six: Miscellaneous Provisions

(20) The Constitution and the Criminal Code (2013) shall extend fully to all parts Independent Order, including the forum, NationStates region, official chatroom and any official off-forum locations. Additionally:
(22) If any individual in a position established by this Constitution fails to log in to the forum for a period of fourteen days without posting a Leave of Absence they shall be deemed as having vacated their position. Vacancies, including those arising from resignation, shall be filled:

(22) An eligible member is one who has been a member of the forum for a period of at least 45 days, has made more than 20 non-spam posts on the forum, and is not serving any form of sentence under the Criminal Code (2013) or the Forum Terms of Service Act (2015).

Explanatory note (not part of Constitution)

This constitution replaces the existing Constitution of the Independent Order. It sets out that the Grand Chancellor will be the head of state, government and commander-in-chief, and will have certain  functions + forum administrative powers. The Regional Assembly maintains its current powers, but adds to it all the powers of the Roleplay Council. It includes a section on the Roleplay Magistrate, who is responsible for enforcing the RP rules. Finally, it includes the Lord Chief Justice, who is responsible for enforcing general law, appeals and judicial review. The constitution applies everywhere the light touches.

As promised, a Constitution proposal which reflects the current state of the Independent Order. The changes aren't many actually, and allow for things to continue as-is while maintaining a path toward future greater interest from the Order in regional governance.
Title: Re: Proposed Constitution - For The Regional Assembly
Post by: RobertAgira on February 27, 2022, 01:12:18 PM
Might I suggest we have somewhere the definition of "eligible members of the Independent Order" for example I know Pandect is active usually on the RMB but never in Discord or on the forum whereas I know some of us don't maintain active nations on the NS site.
Title: Re: Proposed Constitution - For The Regional Assembly
Post by: CGJ on February 27, 2022, 02:30:58 PM
For the benefit of the group, changes:

Might I suggest we have somewhere the definition of "eligible members of the Independent Order" for example I know Pandect is active usually on the RMB but never in Discord or on the forum whereas I know some of us don't maintain active nations on the NS site.

Very last clause: (22) An eligible member is one who has been a member of the forum for a period of at least 45 days, has made more than 20 non-spam posts on the forum, and is not serving any form of sentence under the Criminal Code (2013) or the Forum Terms of Service Act (2015).
Title: Re: Proposed Constitution - For The Regional Assembly
Post by: Achkaerin on February 27, 2022, 02:38:56 PM
"the region into" should be removed from the proposed 2e to make it read "Inducting and expelling, by means of Writ, members of the Regional Nobility;"
Title: Re: Proposed Constitution - For The Regional Assembly
Post by: CGJ on February 27, 2022, 03:01:22 PM
I wonder if the GC recall section should be made more prescriptive, or whether it would be better handled by a GC Recall Act?
Title: Re: Proposed Constitution - For The Regional Assembly
Post by: CGJ on February 27, 2022, 07:10:34 PM
Some amendments from me. Free free to go crazy.

Amendment 1:
(3) Should a petition to recall the Grand Chancellor be signed by five (5) eligible members within the space of 96 hours, the Speaker of the Regional Assembly to oversee a recall referendum of all eligible members. Should no Speaker be in post, the Grand Chancellor shall appoint an eligible member. If 75 per cent of those voting vote to recall, then a Constitutional Convention shall be required to appoint a replacement and the Regional Assembly shall pass an Act of Abdication .

Amendment 2:
(10) Any eligible member may bring forward their own legislation and, with the support of four further eligible members, require the Bill to be signed into law by the Grand Chancellor or brought to a referendum of all eligible members.

Amendment 3:
All references to 'Conference Hall' should be replaced by 'Regional Assembly.'

New clause 1:
(9a) Any eligible member may present amendments in the Conference Hall thread of a Bill. Should an amendment or multiple amendments be presented, there shall be an additional 24 hours, or 48 hours for a Bill amending the Constitution, the Criminal Code, the Roleplay Rules or Emergency Procedures, for debate. Should an amendment go unopposed, it will form part of the final Act. If an amendment is opposed by any eligible member, it should be put to a vote within the thread. 

New clause 2:
(10a) The Conference Hall may adopt Standing Orders to govern its procedures, including the appointment of a Speaker, in accordance with this Constitution.
Title: Re: Proposed Constitution - For The Regional Assembly
Post by: CGJ on February 27, 2022, 09:26:43 PM
Alternatively to the above...

Amendment 1:
(3) Should a petition to recall the Grand Chancellor be signed by five (5) eligible members within the space of 96 hours, the the Grand Chancellor shall appoint an eligible member to oversee a recall referendum of all eligible members. If 75 per cent of those voting vote to recall, then a Constitutional Convention shall be required to appoint a replacement.

Amendment 2:
(10) Any eligible member may bring forward their own legislation and, with the support of four further eligible members, require the Bill to be signed into law by the Grand Chancellor or brought to a referendum of all eligible members.

Amendment 3:
(22) An eligible member is one who has been a member of the forum for a period of at least 45 days, has made more than 20 non-spam posts on the forum, is not serving any form of sentence under the Criminal Code (2013), the Forum Terms of Service Act (2015) or the Discord (Terms of Service) Act (2017), and has not been inactive for a period of 14 days without leave of absence.


New clause:
(9a) Any eligible member may present amendments in the Conference Hall thread of a Bill. Should any amendment be presented, there shall be a minimum additional 24 hours allowed for debate. Should an amendment go unopposed, it will form part of the final Act. If an amendment is opposed by any eligible member, it should be put to a vote within the thread. 
Title: Re: Proposed Constitution - For The Regional Assembly
Post by: CGJ on February 27, 2022, 10:06:53 PM
 My third set of amendments, following Discord discussions. Just wanted to keep the thinking going.

Amendment 1:
(3) Should a petition to recall the Grand Chancellor be signed by five (5) eligible members within the space of 96 hours, the Lord Chief Justice shall organise a recall referendum of all eligible members. If 66 per cent of those voting vote to recall, then the Lord Chief Justice shall organise the election of a new Grand Chancellor.

Amendment 2:
(10) Any eligible member may bring forward their own legislation and, with the support of four further eligible members, require the Bill to be signed into law by the Grand Chancellor or brought to a referendum of all eligible members.

Amendment 3:
(22) An eligible member is one who has been a member of the forum for a period of at least 45 days, has made more than 20 non-spam posts on the forum, is not serving any form of sentence under the Criminal Code (2013), the Forum Terms of Service Act (2015) or the Discord (Terms of Service) Act (2017), and has not been inactive for a period of 14 days without leave of absence.

Amendment 4:
(17) The Lord Chief Justice shall be appointed by the Grand Chancellor, following the same procedure as an Act of the Chancellery, for an indefinite term. Should a petition to recall the Lord Chief Justice be signed by five (5) eligible members within the space of 96 hours, the Grand Chancellor shall organise a recall referendum of all eligible members. If 66 per cent of those voting vote to recall, then the Lord Chief Justice shall be dismissed by the Grand Chancellor.


New clause:
(9a) Any eligible member may present amendments in the Conference Hall thread of a Bill. Should any amendment be presented, there shall be a minimum additional 24 hours allowed for debate. Should an amendment go unopposed, it will form part of the final Act. If an amendment is opposed by any eligible member, it should be put to a vote within the thread.
Title: Re: Proposed Constitution - For The Regional Assembly
Post by: Beatrice on February 28, 2022, 09:09:39 AM
My proposal, minimalist and streamlined, with room for oversight to be added in as needed. I'll write up a Constitution in the coming days to reflect what is represented here, an option that allows for RP players to RP and for those who wish to engage in Government to do so:

(https://i.postimg.cc/9QjdvfvM/Chancellor.png)

Fellow Orderians,

For the past few weeks I've been working on an effort to reforge our Regional Government into a form which will allow for our spheres of role-play and gameplay to co-exist, imposing no pressure upon those who simply wish to RP to participate in regional government and gameplay affairs whilst allowing those who do desire more in the gameplay and governance aspects to take part in them. In the pursuit of this process I also endeavored to streamline the Government of the Independent Order, allowing for an efficient Government which will best represent us at home and abroad. Tonight, I present this plan to you, so that we may discuss it and move towards its adoption.

Orderian Revitalization Program

An Outline For A Reorganized Orderian Government

Section I: Organization And Powers of the Orderian Government
 
The Government of the Independent Order will be reorganized as follows:
 
The Chancellery:
 
The Chancellery will continue to be comprised of the Grand Chancellor and the Vice Chancellor.
 
The Grand Chancellor will work with the advice and guidance of the Privy Council to direct the policies of the Order, to promote both activity and growth of the Order, and to preserve the assets and cultural treasures of the Order. The Grand Chancellor will serve as the Head of Government and Head of State, and the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces.

The Chancellery will represent the 'executive' branch of the Order's Government and will be empowered to act in the best interests of the region. The Grand Chancellor shall act, in their duties as Head of State, as the Order's chief diplomatic agent.
 
The Privy Council:
 
The Privy Council shall serve to advise the Grand Chancellor on policy and to operate the office under their purview. The Vice Chancellor shall head the Privy Council, which will be composed of the following Officers of the Order:
 
Lord Chief Justice
Roleplay Moderator
World Assembly Delegate
Regional Affairs Liaison
 
The Body Politic:
 
The Body Politic of the Independent Order will be an assembly comprised of all Orderians for the discussion and debate of the Order's policies, as well as a forum from which the concerns and ideas of Orderians may be presented for the consideration of the regional government.
 
Section II: Domestic and Foreign Policies of the Order
 
Foreign:
 
The Order will maintain a foreign policy of engaging with regions we may cooperate with. With this being said, the Order will not engage with diplomacy or relations with regions who exhibit extremist policies, nor will it entertain relations with regions who disrupt the peace and tranquility of other regions. It will also support the right of all regions to self-determination, while acting (when it is capable of doing so) to dissuade the attempts of other regions to disrupt the domestic tranquility of regions abroad.
 
Domestic:
 
Recognizing our population of players who seek only to RP, no burdens or expectations will be imposed upon them to participate in the Regional Government. Those who wish solely to RP may do so, while those who wish to take part in the governance of the region shall be able to do so.
 
Section III: Repeal Of Obsolete Acts and Amendments To Standing Laws

I will be conducting a review of Orderian Acts and, with the consultation of our regional officers, will determine those which are obsolete and of no further use to the Independent Order. This section will be updated once that process has been completed.

This topic is open for the consideration of any ideas which Orderians may wish to put forward for inclusion in this process. Together, I am confident we will see a year of expanding opportunities for our region as we grow in numbers, and expand our reach into other spheres of regional gameplay.
Title: Re: Proposed Constitution - For The Regional Assembly
Post by: Altona on March 17, 2022, 11:03:40 PM
If we're going to try and fix the problems this needs to be moved forward.

A few issues with the proposal which I was hoping this constitution might address.

1. Privvy Council - No idea who it consists of at the moment but it will be headed by CGJ who isn't active, and then made up of Dave and Ach, infact Ach holds two of the four positions and I've no idea who the Regional Affairs Liason is or what they do. I assume they'd be in the new constitution.

2. There is a lot of talk of "Foreign Affairs". Things need to be kept focused on sorting out this place first.