1
Office of the Chancellory / Motion for the Recall of the Grand Chancellor of the Independent Order
« on: August 22, 2023, 02:35:08 AM »
Fellow Orderians,
The Constitution of the Independent Order, as revised in April of 2022, states that as part the Grand Chancellor's role is, quote, "Administering the forum, the official chatroom of the region, the NationStates region, and any other official off-forum locations". However, as we have seen time and time again, both under the current constitution as well as that which preceded it, our Grand Chancellor, Beatrice, has shown herself incapable of fairly executing that task, as can be seen with the recent banning of Geo for merely speaking in a channel which was not locked nor had any reason to be prohibited. This act is merely the continuation of a long line of incidents involving our Grand Chancellor, who has normally executed her job with the respect which such a title deserves. We saw it when Nova left the region, citing in the post titled "Are we masochists?" an inability on the part of Beatrice to differentiate between real life and the rp, which has led to many instances whereupon the most benign of criticism has been met with hostility and further abuses of her power.
We also saw on repeated occasions that Beatrice has caused drama within the community. One of the most visible cases of this are the spats between her and Cass starting over interpretations of international law, ultimately building up to the drafting of the current constitution. Such actions as these, as well as numerous more cases, suggest to any prospective new members that the Independent Order is not a community which is worth remaining in. After all, the Office of the Grand Chancellor is also required to conduct diplomacy with other regions and is, for lack of a better term, the effective face of our community. Can we really be a welcoming community while such an important figure, whether intentionally or not, acts in such a manner that runs contrary to that? Can we accept someone who has shown themselves time and time again willing to abuse their authority and privileges when someone slights them, rather than genuinely causing trouble for the community as a whole? I think not, and so, though I wish I was not forced to take this most drastic of steps, I am formally calling for the recall of Beatrice as Grand Chancellor of the Independent Order, with CGJ to take her position until such a time as elections for a new Grand Chancellor can be held. I cite Article 8, Section VI of the Criminal Code, which states, quote, "Anyone who knowingly commits other actions unbecoming of an administrator or moderator...is guilty of the offense of Abuse of Administrative Powers under this law and liable to a punishment at judicial discretion." I recognize that some among us may take issue with this decision, but we have reached a point where it can be ignored no longer, thus necessitating this action be taken.
Thank you for your time, and may our Independent Order remain strong as it goes into the future.
Provided below are a collection of screenshots providing two instances of this abuse of power and unbecoming behavior on the part of the Grand Chancellor.
The Constitution of the Independent Order, as revised in April of 2022, states that as part the Grand Chancellor's role is, quote, "Administering the forum, the official chatroom of the region, the NationStates region, and any other official off-forum locations". However, as we have seen time and time again, both under the current constitution as well as that which preceded it, our Grand Chancellor, Beatrice, has shown herself incapable of fairly executing that task, as can be seen with the recent banning of Geo for merely speaking in a channel which was not locked nor had any reason to be prohibited. This act is merely the continuation of a long line of incidents involving our Grand Chancellor, who has normally executed her job with the respect which such a title deserves. We saw it when Nova left the region, citing in the post titled "Are we masochists?" an inability on the part of Beatrice to differentiate between real life and the rp, which has led to many instances whereupon the most benign of criticism has been met with hostility and further abuses of her power.
We also saw on repeated occasions that Beatrice has caused drama within the community. One of the most visible cases of this are the spats between her and Cass starting over interpretations of international law, ultimately building up to the drafting of the current constitution. Such actions as these, as well as numerous more cases, suggest to any prospective new members that the Independent Order is not a community which is worth remaining in. After all, the Office of the Grand Chancellor is also required to conduct diplomacy with other regions and is, for lack of a better term, the effective face of our community. Can we really be a welcoming community while such an important figure, whether intentionally or not, acts in such a manner that runs contrary to that? Can we accept someone who has shown themselves time and time again willing to abuse their authority and privileges when someone slights them, rather than genuinely causing trouble for the community as a whole? I think not, and so, though I wish I was not forced to take this most drastic of steps, I am formally calling for the recall of Beatrice as Grand Chancellor of the Independent Order, with CGJ to take her position until such a time as elections for a new Grand Chancellor can be held. I cite Article 8, Section VI of the Criminal Code, which states, quote, "Anyone who knowingly commits other actions unbecoming of an administrator or moderator...is guilty of the offense of Abuse of Administrative Powers under this law and liable to a punishment at judicial discretion." I recognize that some among us may take issue with this decision, but we have reached a point where it can be ignored no longer, thus necessitating this action be taken.
Thank you for your time, and may our Independent Order remain strong as it goes into the future.
Provided below are a collection of screenshots providing two instances of this abuse of power and unbecoming behavior on the part of the Grand Chancellor.
Spoiler: show